AQA GCSE in English Literature · Free · no account needed

Grade 9 Notes: When We Two Parted

Lord Byron · A Love and Relationships poem on AQA GCSE English Literature (8702) — not on Pearson Edexcel International GCSE (4ET1) · When We Two Parted

When We Two Parted is four short stanzas spoken by someone who was secretly in love, was left, and now hears the other person's name spoken with scandal. Revise it as a poem of two partings: the private one in the past, in silence and tears, and the public one in the present, when gossip tells the speaker what the beloved has become. The poem's power lives in the gap between what the speaker knows and what everyone else knows — and in the way it ends exactly where it began. Learn six or seven short phrases exactly, because if this is your partner poem you will need them from memory: the opening and closing ‘silence and tears’, the ‘chill’ dew, ‘light is thy fame’, the ‘knell’, ‘knew thee too well’, ‘In secret we met’.

Build your reading of When We Two Parted, teach it to an AI pupil, then defend it in a marked debate — this page carries all three.

What is this exam testing?

When We Two Parted is examined on one course Incandio supports: AQA GCSE English Literature (8702), as one of the fifteen poems in the Love and Relationships cluster on Paper 2. You meet it in one of two ways — printed on the paper as the named poem, or remembered as the poem you choose to set beside a different named poem. Both routes reward the same three things: an argument of your own (AO1), close attention to how the poem's language, form and structure make that argument (AO2), and context that genuinely changes how a line reads (AO3 — on this course AO3 means context, not comparison). For When We Two Parted that means a view about what the poem does with a secret love and its ending, a handful of exact phrases, and one or two pieces of context — the Regency world of reputation and gossip — welded to a line.

AQA GCSE English Literature (8702) — Paper 2, Section B: Poetry (Love and Relationships)

Section B asks one comparative question on the cluster. One poem is named and printed; you choose a second from the same cluster and write about it from memory. There is no separate mark for comparing: comparison is the task itself, credited through the quality of your argument and your analysis. Accuracy of spelling and grammar (AO4) is not credited on this question, though clear writing still carries the argument. On Pearson Edexcel International GCSE the same AO codes mean different things; never carry them across.

AO1 · A personal, critical response, supported by references

What the examiner wants: An argument about what the poem does, not a retelling of a break-up. On When We Two Parted the strongest arguments ask whose pain this is: a heartbroken lover's, a betrayed one's, or a proud one's.

Scoring highly: Move across the whole poem with short references — the parting in the past, the dew as warning, the name spoken in public, the secret meetings — and keep the comparison alive in every paragraph rather than saving it for the end.

Top band vs the band below: Top answers treat the poem as something built: noticing that the speaker never says what the beloved did is an observation; arguing that the silence is the poem's method — that it withholds the scandal so the reader shares the speaker's position as the one who cannot speak — is a concept.

The common mistake: Writing as though the poem tells a clear story of who betrayed whom. It never says what happened; an answer that invents the details has stopped reading the poem.

In your essay: Open with a comparative thesis that names both poems and the difference that matters, then build three or four paragraphs that each hold both poems, and finish on what the pairing shows that neither poem shows alone.

AO2 · Language, form and structure, with subject terminology

What the examiner wants: Analysis of Byron's methods: short, heavily stressed lines; alternating rhyme; the circular structure; the movement from past to present tense; the archaic second person ‘thee’ and ‘thy’; sound — the knell, the shudder; and the poem's rhetorical question.

Scoring highly: Read the form as feeling: the lines are so short that each one lands like a held breath, and the poem's first and last stanzas meet in the same phrase so the speaker is shown unable to move on.

Top band vs the band below: The best answers connect a sound to an argument: the bell-like ‘knell’ turns the beloved's name into a death, so the gossip becomes a funeral for the relationship the speaker cannot attend in public.

The common mistake: Calling the language ‘old-fashioned’ and stopping. ‘Thee’ and ‘thy’ are intimate forms of address; say what speaking to someone so intimately, in a poem about not being able to speak, does.

In your essay: In each paragraph name the method, pin down the words or moment doing the work, say what it does to a reader, then say what the partner poem does differently. Make at least one point about form or structure.

AO3 · Context — the relationship between the poem and the world it comes from

What the examiner wants: How the world of the poem shapes it: a society in which reputation (‘fame’) could be ruined by gossip, in which a love affair might have to be secret, and in which the double standard fell hardest on women. The poem was first published in 1816.

Scoring highly: One clause at a time, welded to a line: in a society where a reputation could be destroyed by rumour, ‘light is thy fame’ is not a small thing — it is the beloved's social ruin, and the speaker shares it in private.

Top band vs the band below: Context that generates a reading: because the love was secret, the speaker has no public right to grieve, so the ‘silence’ of the last stanza is enforced by the world as much as chosen by the self.

The common mistake: A paragraph about Byron's own scandals. The poem names no one and gives no dates; biography that cannot be tied to a line earns nothing and risks being wrong.

In your essay: Two or three contextual clauses across the essay, each welded to a moment in a poem and each changing what that moment means. Never a paragraph of background on its own.

Avoid. Treating the poem as a simple break-up poem. The break-up is over before the poem starts; what the poem is about is what came afterwards — hearing the name, keeping the secret, and not being able to stop feeling.

Examiner insight. A strong comparative opening names a method, not just a subject: ‘Both poems remember a love that ended, but Byron's circular form traps his speaker inside the grief, while Hardy's frame lets his speaker look back on it as a lesson learned.’

If you choose this as your partner poem, carry its shape as well as its phrases: four stanzas of eight short lines, alternate rhymes, the past tense of the parting giving way to the present tense of the gossip, and the last line returning to the first stanza's words.

The speaker and the figures

The speaker

A secret lover who was left, and who now hears the beloved's name spoken in public

The speaker remembers a parting that happened years before, in silence and tears, and reads its coldness as a warning of what was to come. Now the beloved's vows are broken and their reputation is spoken of lightly; others mention the name in the speaker's hearing, not knowing the two were ever close. The speaker cannot say anything. The poem is the speech the speaker is not allowed to make in public: grief, bitterness and a lasting attachment, held together in lines so short they sound like restraint. The speaker is never named or given a gender, which lets the poem stand for anyone who has had to hide a loss.

The first parting: silence, tears and a warning

The poem opens on the moment of separation, years before. Neither lover speaks; both cry. The speaker remembers the beloved's face and kiss growing cold, and reads that coldness now as a sign of what the relationship would become.

“When we two parted / In silence and tears” — The speaker, Stanza 1

The opening sets the pattern of the whole poem: a love that could not be spoken even at its end. The pairing of silence with tears makes the grief physical but wordless, and the phrase will return in the final line.

Methods: circular structure · pairing

“Pale grew thy cheek and cold, / Colder thy kiss” — The speaker, Stanza 1

The comparative ‘Colder’ intensifies the image line by line. A pale, cold cheek and kiss suggest death as much as departure, so the relationship is mourned before anyone has died.

Methods: comparative · imagery of death

“Truly that hour foretold / Sorrow to this” — The speaker, Stanza 1

Looking back, the speaker reads the parting as a prophecy. The poem moves from past to present in these lines, and ‘this’ points at a present sorrow the poem has not yet explained.

Methods: foreshadowing · shift in time

The second parting: the name in public

In the second and third stanzas the poem arrives in the present. The beloved's vows are broken and their reputation is talked about; the speaker hears the name spoken and shares, silently, in its shame.

“Thy vows are all broken, / And light is thy fame” — The speaker, Stanza 2

‘Fame’ here means reputation, and ‘light’ means slight or loose. The beloved has broken promises — to the speaker, or to someone else, the poem does not say — and is now gossiped about.

Methods: ambiguity · archaic sense

“I hear thy name spoken, / And share in its shame” — The speaker, Stanza 2

The alliteration of ‘share’ and ‘shame’ binds the speaker to the scandal. No one knows of the connection, yet the speaker feels the disgrace as their own.

Methods: alliteration · irony

“They know not I knew thee, / Who knew thee too well” — The speaker, Stanza 3

The repetition of ‘knew’ turns on the double sense of knowing someone. The others do not know of the relationship; the speaker knew the beloved ‘too well’ — intimately, and perhaps well enough to have seen this coming.

Methods: repetition · dramatic irony

The ending: back to silence

The last stanza returns to the secret meetings and to the speaker's present grief, then imagines meeting the beloved again after many years. The answer to how the speaker would greet them is the poem's opening phrase.

The ending can be read in two directions. As faithfulness, it shows a love so deep that years change nothing; the speaker would still weep. As entrapment, it shows a mind stuck at the moment of loss, unable to imagine any other response. The poem gives both readings the same evidence, which is why the final stanza rewards an argument rather than a summary.

“In secret we met— / In silence I grieve” — The speaker, Stanza 4

The two short clauses mirror each other: the meeting was secret, and so the grief must be silent. The secrecy that made the love possible is what now prevents the speaker from mourning it openly.

Methods: parallelism · cause and effect

“How should I greet thee?— / With silence and tears” — The speaker, Stanza 4

The question looks to the future and finds only the past. Ending with the opening phrase closes the circle: the speaker is imagined repeating the first parting for ever.

Methods: rhetorical question · cyclical ending

How Byron builds the speaker in language and structure

The lines are very short — usually two strong beats — so the speaker seems to speak in clipped, controlled bursts, as if anything longer would break down.

The alternating rhyme (parted/hearted, tears/years) is regular and tight; the feeling is held in a strict pattern, which suggests restraint rather than release.

The poem moves from a past-tense memory in stanza one to present-tense feeling — ‘I hear’, ‘I grieve’ — so the reader watches the old wound reopen.

The ending repeats the opening phrase, giving the poem a circular structure: the speaker imagines the future and finds only a repeat of the past.

The speaker in context

Reputation. In the early nineteenth century a person's ‘fame’ — their reputation — could be destroyed by gossip, and affairs outside marriage were conducted in secret. That is why the love must be hidden and why the speaker cannot grieve openly.

Publication. The poem was first published in 1816. It names no one and gives no setting, which allows it to speak for anyone whose love had to stay secret.

Relationships

  • The beloved — Addressed throughout as ‘thee’, but never named or described beyond a cold cheek and a ruined reputation. The speaker's feelings towards them move between longing, reproach and grief.
  • The others — ‘They’ who name the beloved in the speaker's hearing. They represent society and its gossip, and their ignorance of the relationship is what keeps the speaker silent.

What The speaker stands for

  • Silence: what the speaker cannot say, and what society will not allow.
  • Cold and chill: the death of feeling, and a warning of it.
  • The name: reputation, spoken by others, wounding to hear.

Why Byron made The speaker

  • To show how a secret love leaves its survivor with grief that cannot be shared.
  • To dramatise the gap between private feeling and public reputation.
  • To make the reader decide whether the speaker's pain is heartbreak, wounded pride, or both.

The speaker: all 11 quotations in the When We Two Parted quote bank, analysed →

Other readings

  • A wronged lover: the beloved broke vows and the speaker is the injured party.
  • A proud lover: the speaker's sense of ‘shame’ is as much about their own name as about lost love.
  • A lover trapped by secrecy: the real cruelty is not the beloved's but the world's, which forbids open grief.

Essay arguments

  • Byron presents a speaker whose love must stay hidden, so the poem itself becomes the only place the grief can be spoken.
  • The circular ending presents the speaker as trapped: the future greeting is imagined as a repeat of the past parting.
  • The speaker's feelings are mixed — tender, bitter and ashamed — and the poem refuses to settle them into one.

In theme essays

  • Memory: the parting remembered as a warning.
  • Secrecy and reputation: love that cannot be spoken of in public.
  • Loss: grief that is ongoing, not finished.

Questions that get asked

  • How does Byron present the effects of a relationship ending in When We Two Parted and one other poem from the cluster?
  • Compare the ways poets show memory and regret in When We Two Parted and one other poem from Love and Relationships.

The beloved (‘thee’)

The person the speaker loved in secret, who broke their vows and whose name is now spoken lightly

The beloved is present only through the speaker's memory and the speaker's reports of gossip. We learn that at the parting their cheek grew pale and their kiss cold; that their vows are now broken; that their reputation is ‘light’; that their heart could ‘forget’ and their spirit ‘deceive’. Every one of these details is the speaker's judgement, and the beloved never speaks. That silence is the poem's own form of unfairness — or of discretion — and a reader can question whether the beloved is a betrayer or simply someone the speaker could not keep.

Seen only through the speaker

Every detail about the beloved comes filtered through hurt. The cold cheek and kiss are remembered with hindsight, and the accusations in the final stanza are the speaker's.

“That thy heart could forget, / Thy spirit deceive” — The speaker, Stanza 4

The speaker's grief turns to reproach: the beloved is accused of forgetting and deceiving. Because the beloved never answers, the reader has only one side of the story.

Methods: accusation · parallelism

“They name thee before me, / A knell to mine ear” — The speaker, Stanza 3

A knell is the bell rung for a death. Hearing the beloved's name in public sounds like a funeral bell, as if the person the speaker loved has died and only the scandal survives.

Methods: metaphor · sound imagery

“Why wert thou so dear?” — The speaker, Stanza 3

The question is addressed to the absent beloved and receives no answer. It asks why the attachment was so strong, and why it still is.

Methods: rhetorical question · apostrophe

How Byron builds the beloved in language and structure

The beloved is addressed in the intimate second person — ‘thee’, ‘thy’ — throughout, so the poem speaks to someone who is not there to hear.

Details of the beloved are physical and cold in the first stanza and moral in the last: from cheek and kiss to heart and spirit, from body to character.

The beloved is never given a line of their own; the structure keeps them silent, as society's gossip keeps the speaker silent.

The beloved in context

The double standard. A ‘light’ fame suggests a reputation for looseness or infidelity. In the period the double standard meant such talk damaged women far more than men, though the poem never gives the beloved a gender.

Vows. Broken ‘vows’ may mean promises made to the speaker or marriage vows made to someone else; the poem keeps this open, and an essay should too.

Relationships

  • The speaker — Loved in secret; now the speaker's grief and reproach are the only account of them.
  • Society — Speaks the beloved's name lightly, damaging their reputation.

What The beloved (‘thee’) stands for

  • The cold kiss: love already dying at the parting.
  • The broken vows: promises that no longer bind.

Why Byron made The beloved (‘thee’)

  • To give the reader a figure who is judged but never heard.
  • To show how a reputation is made by other people's words.

The beloved: all 5 quotations in the When We Two Parted quote bank, analysed →

Other readings

  • A betrayer who broke faith.
  • A victim of gossip and of a society quicker to shame than to understand.
  • A blank onto which the speaker projects grief.

Essay arguments

  • The beloved never speaks, so Byron leaves the reader to judge an absent figure from one wounded account.
  • The beloved's ruined reputation is the public event that reopens the speaker's private wound.

In theme essays

  • Reputation: the beloved's ‘fame’.
  • Betrayal: broken vows.

Questions that get asked

  • How is the absent beloved presented in When We Two Parted?
  • Compare the ways poets show an absent or distant loved one in When We Two Parted and one other poem.

The themes

Secrecy and silence

A love that had to be hidden leaves grief that cannot be spoken.

Silence frames the poem: the lovers parted in silence and the speaker imagines greeting the beloved in silence again. Between those two silences comes the one thing the speaker hears — the beloved's name in other people's mouths. The secrecy that made the love possible is exactly what makes it impossible to mourn: no one knows, so no one can be told.

The poem is itself a breaking of that silence, but only on paper. The short lines and tight rhymes keep the outburst controlled, so even the poem sounds as if it is speaking under its breath.

Use this in an essay. Byron makes silence both the cause and the shape of the speaker's suffering: the love was secret, so the grief must be silent, and the poem's circular form returns the speaker to silence at the end.

3 quotations on secrecy and silence in the When We Two Parted quote bank, analysed →

Loss, memory and time

The past keeps returning in the present.

The poem moves from a parting ‘years’ ago to a present in which the speaker still grieves, and then imagines a meeting ‘After long years’. Time passes but the feeling does not change. Memory works as foreshadowing: the dew and the cold kiss are remembered as warnings of the present sorrow.

The cyclical structure makes the same point formally. The last line repeats the first stanza's phrase, so time in the poem goes round rather than forward.

Memory in the poem is not neutral recall. The speaker rereads the past through present pain, so details that may have meant nothing at the time — a pale cheek, the chill of the morning dew — are remembered as omens. That is how grief often works: it reorganises the past around the loss. An essay can argue that the poem shows memory being rewritten by feeling, which is why the speaker's account cannot simply be trusted as a record of what happened.

10 quotations on loss, memory and time in the When We Two Parted quote bank, analysed →

Reputation and society (minor)

Other people's talk decides what the beloved has become.

The second half of the poem is driven by gossip: the beloved's ‘fame’ is ‘light’, the name is spoken, and the speaker ‘shares’ in the shame. Society is present as an anonymous ‘They’ who know a scandal but not the love behind it.

The speaker's shame is curious: no one knows of the relationship, so the shame is felt rather than imposed. A reader can see this as loyalty — the speaker still feels bound to the beloved — or as wounded pride.

The gossip also exposes a kind of injustice. The people who speak the name know a scandal but not a person; the one who knew the person best is the one who may not speak. Byron sets public knowledge, which is shallow and cruel, against private knowledge, which is deep and silenced. That contrast is a strong basis for a paragraph on how society shapes love in this cluster.

3 quotations on reputation and society in the When We Two Parted quote bank, analysed →

Betrayal and bitterness (minor)

Grief turns, at moments, into reproach.

The beloved's ‘vows are all broken’ and their heart could ‘forget’ and spirit ‘deceive’. These lines give the poem an edge of accusation, but they sit beside the tender question ‘Why wert thou so dear?’ The poem holds love and resentment together without choosing between them.

Because the beloved never answers, the accusations are untested. A careful reader can ask whether the speaker's bitterness is justified or whether it is the natural unfairness of someone hurt. Raising that question — rather than repeating the accusation as fact — is a mark of a critical response.

3 quotations on betrayal and bitterness in the When We Two Parted quote bank, analysed →

Context

Context: reputation, secrecy and the poem's world

Reputation. The poem was first published in 1816, in a society where reputation mattered enormously. Among the upper classes, love affairs outside marriage were common but had to be secret, and discovery could mean public disgrace. A person's ‘fame’ meant their good name, and once it became ‘light’ it was hard to restore. The double standard of the time meant that women's reputations were judged far more harshly than men's.

Why it matters. This world explains the poem's central problem. Because the love was secret, the speaker has no public right to grieve or to defend the beloved. When others mention the name, the speaker must listen in silence. The poem's insistence on silence is therefore not only a personal choice but a social necessity, and context lets an essay say so: the silence is enforced as well as chosen.

Use this context in single clauses attached to lines — ‘In secret we met’, ‘light is thy fame’ — rather than in a separate paragraph about the period.

Form, voice and comparison

Form: short lines and a tight pattern

Four stanzas of eight lines each, rhyming alternately. The lines are very short, most with two strong beats, so the poem sounds clipped and restrained. Feeling is held in, not poured out.

The regular rhyme scheme gives the poem the sound of a song or lyric, which sharpens the contrast with what it describes: a private grief that has no public outlet.

Structure: a circle in time

The poem begins in the past (the parting), moves through the present (the gossip, the grief) and ends by imagining the future (a meeting after long years). But the future greeting is described with the opening words — silence and tears — so the structure is circular.

The circle can be read as faithfulness — the speaker will always feel the same — or as entrapment — the speaker cannot move on.

Language: cold, sound and the second person

Cold runs through the first two stanzas: a pale, cold cheek, a colder kiss, a dew that ‘Sunk chill’. Sound becomes important in the third stanza, where the name is a ‘knell’ and the speaker feels ‘A shudder’. The intimate ‘thee’ and ‘thy’ make the whole poem an address to someone absent.

Comparison: the strongest partners

Neutral Tones (Hardy) is the closest partner: both remember the end of a love, both use cold, deadened imagery, and both have a circular or framed structure. The difference is that Hardy's speaker draws a lesson — love deceives — while Byron's remains inside the grief.

Love's Philosophy (Shelley) offers contrast: a lover pleading for a love that has not yet happened, against Byron's grieving for one that is over. Both use questions to end, but Shelley's is persuasive while Byron's is despairing.

Porphyria's Lover (Browning) also deals with secret love and a lover's desire to keep the beloved; set beside it, Byron's speaker is passive and grieving where Browning's is violent and possessive.

Grade 9 insight. Compare methods, not just subjects: Byron's circular form against Hardy's frame; Byron's restraint against Browning's calm, chilling narration.

Key words and what they carry

fame: Reputation — what people say of someone. ‘Light is thy fame’ means the lover's good name has become slight and loose.

sever: To cut apart. The verb makes the parting an injury rather than a drift.

knell: The bell rung for a death or a funeral. The lover's name, spoken, sounds like one.

rue: To regret bitterly. ‘Long, long shall I rue thee’ keeps resentment inside the grief.

Precision with these words is an AO2 advantage. Many answers misread ‘fame’ as celebrity and lose the poem's central point about reputation; an answer that reads it correctly can connect the language directly to the poem's world, where a good name could be lost to gossip and never recovered. Treat each of these words as a small piece of evidence that carries both meaning and feeling.

Readings to weigh

Another reading. A heartbreak reading: the speaker is simply devastated, and the poem's restraint is grief too deep for words.

Another reading. A pride reading: the speaker's ‘shame’ and reproach show wounded pride; the poem is as much about the speaker's feelings as the beloved's fate.

Another reading. A social reading: the real antagonist is the society that forced the love into secrecy and now gossips about it.

Shock the examiner: what most answers miss

Most answers say the poem is about a break-up. The break-up happened years before the poem begins. The event the poem actually reports is hearing a name spoken in public — so the poem is about gossip as much as about love.

The speaker feels ‘shame’ about a scandal no one connects to them. That is a strange feeling, and worth arguing about: is it loyalty to the beloved, or the speaker's fear for their own name?

‘Half broken-hearted’ is often skipped. Why only half? One reading: the heartbreak was not complete at the parting, and the gossip has finished the job.

The poem never gives the beloved a gender, a name or a voice. An essay that notices how one-sided the evidence is can question the speaker's accusations rather than simply repeating them.

The final question — how should I greet thee? — is answered with the first stanza's words. The future is imagined as the past. That is the poem's most important structural fact, and it can carry a whole paragraph.

Thesis statements

  • Byron presents a love whose secrecy outlives it: because no one knew, no one can be told, and the poem becomes the only place the grief is spoken.
  • The circular structure of When We Two Parted traps the speaker in the moment of separation, so that even an imagined future meeting repeats the first parting.
  • The poem is less about a break-up than about gossip: the event it reports is hearing a name spoken lightly in public.
  • Byron holds tenderness and reproach together without resolving them, so the reader cannot be sure whether the speaker is heartbroken or proud.
  • Cold, deathly imagery turns a parting into a bereavement, and the beloved's name into a funeral bell.

Essay plans

Compare the ways poets show the end of a relationship in When We Two Parted and one other poem from Love and Relationships.

Thesis: Both Byron and Hardy remember a love's ending through cold, deadened imagery, but Byron's circular form leaves his speaker trapped in grief, while Hardy's frame lets his speaker turn the memory into a bitter lesson.

  1. Cold imagery: Byron's pale cheek and colder kiss against Hardy's white sun and grey leaves — both make the ending feel like a death.
  2. Structure: Byron returns to ‘silence and tears’; Hardy returns to the pond at the end — but Hardy adds a lesson, Byron only a repetition.
  3. Voice and secrecy: Byron's speaker cannot speak in public; Hardy's speaker addresses the lover directly in the past.
  4. Context and judgement: Byron's Regency world of reputation makes the grief secret; Hardy's speaker generalises to all love. Conclude on trapped grief against learned bitterness.

Compare the ways poets show feelings of longing in When We Two Parted and one other poem.

Thesis: Byron's longing looks back at a love that is over and cannot be mourned in public; Shelley's looks forward to a love not yet given — so one poem's questions despair while the other's persuade.

  1. The questions: ‘Why wert thou so dear?’ against Shelley's closing question — despair against persuasion.
  2. Nature: Byron's chill dew as warning; Shelley's mingling rivers as argument.
  3. Form: Byron's short, restrained lines; Shelley's flowing, insistent ones.
  4. What the longing achieves: Byron's ends in silence; Shelley's ends unanswered. Conclude on past against future longing.

Think you understand it?

Reading is the start. On Incandio a topic counts as mastered only once you have taught it and defended it — the two things a revision guide cannot ask of you.

Incandio this topic → Prove it. Teach it. Defend it. What does “Incandio it” mean?

  1. Teach it — Pick a reading above and explain your interpretation of it to Ember, an AI pupil who has not made one. Every study on this page has its own gate.
  2. Defend it — Hold your reading of When We Two Parted against the writer in a short, structured debate marked against descriptors you can read first.
  3. Then the exam — exam-style practice, marked on Incandio.

Completely free. No subscriptions, no paywalls, no account needed to start.

Carry on